My Wife Says “Tip!”, I Say “No!” Who’s right? And What’s the Right Price?

A few months ago, the president and CEO of Hilton, Christopher Nassetta, made international news when he mentioned at a hotel industry conference in New York City that he doesn’t tip housekeeping.

IF THE CEO DOESN’T TIP, SHOULD I?

Admittedly, I find tipping to be a very complex subject.

Failing to give a tip after dining at a restaurant, taking a cab ride, or getting help from a porter is a big no-no in the U.S. However, did you know that tipping isn’t a commonplace practice in every country.

DID YOU KNOW?

In some countries, like Australia, tipping is not common and it can even make recipients a bit uncomfortable. China doesn’t have a tipping culture, either. And in Japan (one of my favorite countries), tipping is actually frowned upon because good service is standard and expected.

Pro-Tip: In my experience traveling through Japan, individuals that are connected with the tourism industry do appreciate a discrete tip.

In the U.S, it’s fairly standard to tip 15 – 20% for most services but some countries only expect a 5% tip, while other countries expect nothing at all.

SO WHO DO I TIP & HOW MUCH?

Tipping is extremely personal. After all, most of us want to thank the right people for great service. So, who deserves a tip — and how much should you give?

  • Do you tip the yellow-cab taxi driver? Do you tip an uber/lyft driver?
  • Do you tip an airport curbside porter? Do you tip the airline check-in agent inside the aiport?
  • If you decline housekeeping during your hotel stay, do you tip?
  • Do you tip the valet EVERY TIME they retrieve your car? Does the price of the tip change if you have to retreive your car 10 times in one day?
  • Do you tip airline employees (e.g. flight attendants)?
  • Do you tip a hotel concierge for suggesting a great restaurant? How about suggesting the closest coffee shop?

At this point, who isn’t receiving a tip?

MY RECENT DILEMMA

Recently, I departed from an airport and utilized the airport curbside porter simply because I had a few big bags and didn’t want the hassle of lugging them inside to check.

To be clear, I carried all of my bags from the car to the check-in counter. I placed my bag onto the scale because he stated “we are not allowed to lift any bags.”

But after completing check-in, the porter then said “thank you for checking in with us. We accept cash tips, credit card, and PayPal.”

I took a second and thought to myself “what am I tipping you for? If I took this bag inside, the agent would do the same process that you did and I wouldn’t have to tip anyone sooo…???”

TIP THE VALET?

You may also remember a few months ago when my wife and I stayed at a Kimpton in Nashville for two nights and we had two choices:

  1. self park for ~$30/night (with no in-and-out privileges)
  2. valet park for ~$40/night

I thought those prices were fairly expensive, but I expected to leave the property a few times during our stay so we selected valet parking.

After checking-in and placing our luggage in our room, we returned to our car 10 minutes later so we could grab dinner in town. We returned to the hotel an hour later, once again valeting our car.

An hour after valeting the car we decided to leave the hotel property once again for a quick jaunt to get dessert. Again, we returned to the hotel a few hours later.

Shortly before turning in for the night, we discovered that we had forgotten some supplies for our infant daughter so we, again, requested our car and made a quick trip to Target.

Typically, we don’t leave the hotel as much as we did. However, the second day, we may have requested our car 5 or 6 times throughout the day.

QUESTION OF THE DAY

So here is the question…do you tip the curbside porter even though they don’t touch your bags? If so, why?

In the second example, should I have tipped the valet at the hotel EVERY time I departed from the hotel? How much should I have tipped them each time? And should the price per night (~$40) factor into how much I tip them?

FINAL STAMP

Tipping can be a personal and complex subject, particularly, if you’re traveling in a foreign country.

If you’re really unsure what’s customary, feel free to ask around or err on the side of being overly generous.

Note: If you answered “No, I don’t tip flight attendants,” you may be surprised the next time you fly Frontier Airlines. Frontier recently implemented an inflight tipping program and you will be prompted to add a gratuity after your beverage purchase.

What’s your take on tipping?

6 comments

  1. If the porter is not helping then there is no need to tip. If so, $1 per bag.
    Unless you trash your hotel room, them there’s no reason to tip. But if you’re asking the cleaning attendants for extra pillows, blankets, etc it might require some gaturity. However, sometimes in small countries, I leave some loose local money. It would cost me too much to switch it back into USD.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Great food for thought.
    I’m with you, if you didn’t do anything, what am I tipping you for. I guess the tip for the porter is for when he takes the bag from the curb inside. So why not………if you can, just go a few more steps inside and go to the ticket counter……….unless there’s a long line inside. I was always told $2 per bag. I try to carry-on, unless traveling with my husband. He does not want to be bothered so we check bags (and I still have a carry-on. 😂
    As for the valet parking, the price per day should be enough to pay the parking attendant no matter how many times you ask for your car. If you pay $30 per day, you should also be able to go get your car anytime you desire. Rip-off!!!!!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Normally, I would’ve gone inside but I had three large bags and there was quite a bit of distance between the car and inside counter. Interestingly, the porter station had baggage belts so he just had to place them on the belts and not have to take them inside at all. Does that require a tip?

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s