Does Applying For A New Credit Card Hurt My Credit Score?

I enjoy telling everyone (who will listen) about the amazing value they can achieve by maximizing credit cards and using them responsibly. The amount of points that you can receive from one sign-up bonus can, typically, be enough points to have you in a comfortable lie-flat seat in the front of the plane. Incredible!

There are so many great credit cards out there that I find it difficult to keep track. However, when I’m talking to a skeptic about credit cards, there’s one misconception I hear more than any other and it usually sounds like this: “…but I heard that applying for credit cards is bad for your credit score.”

Is There Any Truth To This Notion?

Although my score recently went down, I have 18 credit cards and my score remains “excellent.” How is this possible? Let’s take a look…

You may remember THIS BLOG where I detailed how your credit score is determined.

In short, your score is comprised of:
– 35% = payment history (the percentage of payments you’ve made on-time)
– 30% = credit utilization (the percentage of credit you’re using compared to your total limit you’ve been given by the bank)
– 15% = credit age (the average age of your open accounts)
– 10% = types of credit you use (how many different types of requests for credit you have)
– 10% = requests for new credit (how many times you’ve applied for credit)

I want to focus on credit utilization. This is where adding a new credit card to your credit file actually helps boost your your credit scores in the long run.

As you can see, credit utilization makes up a significant amount of your credit score (30%) and is calculated by adding all your credit card balances at any given time and dividing that by your total credit limit.

The Good Side (…with a real life example)

Let’s say that you have one credit card with a $5,000 credit limit and you spend $5,000 on it total per month. You’re utilizing 100% of your credit ($5,000 / $5,000). <—Even if you can pay it off, DO NOT DO THIS!!! I’m telling you from real life experience!

Now, let’s say, you have 10 credit cards with a $5,000 credit line each (thus $50,000 of available credit), and you still spend $5,000 per month. You’re only utilizing 10% of your credit ($5,000 / $50,000).

Your utilization ratio has decreased from 100% to 10%. Experts suggest keeping your utilization ratio below 30% but, for the best scores, below 10%. 

Utilizing 100% will have a HUGE negative impact on your credit score. Why? Card issuers put you in 3 categories…low-risk, medium risk, or high risk. They are, ultimately, worried if you’re going to pay them back. Utilizing 100% of your credit line puts you, solidly, in the “high risk” category and that is not where you want to be.

Meanwhile, if you have a lot of credit available to you but you’re not using it, card issuers view that as low risk, because they can see how responsible you are.

The Bad Side (…if there really is a bad side)

“…But My Score Went Down When I Applied For A Credit Card, Why?

You’re right! When you apply for a new credit card, the credit card issuer will, typically, do a ‘hard pull’ on your credit. They want to determine if they should extend credit to you. <–This is why a good score is critical. Once they perform the ‘hard pull,’ the impact varies by person but each inquiry will, typically, “ding” your score about 2-3 points. Credit scores max out at 850, so a 2-3 point drop is basically nothing.

This is the only consistent downside to applying for credit cards.

The other downside (though it doesn’t have to be a downside) is that your average age of accounts (10% of your credit score) decreases. For example, let’s say you previously had just one credit card for 10 years, and you apply and are approved for a new card. Now your average account age will be five years (10 years / 2 cards). The way to prevent this from being a problem is to keep a few credit cards open for a long time.

A Real Life Example

Let’s take a look at my credit score…

screen shot via creditkarma.com

… and the factors affecting my credit score…

credit factors via creditkarma.com

As you can see here, on the “high impact areas” I do fairly well — 100% of my payments are on-time, low credit utilization, and zero derogatory marks. My age of credit history could be better but I’ve applied for a lot of cards to test my theories for blogs…I call it “market research.” 😉

I want to be completely open and honest…when I applied for my first credit card, my score was in the upper 500’s. I’m not quite sure how it got that low but regardless I worked at making it better. I don’t have a clear timeline on how fast you can improve your individual score because I spent a lot of time testing different theories. But my situation isn’t an isolated incident. Many of my family members agreed to assist me when I began testing my theories and every single person has improved their score with my assistance.

FINAL STAMP

It’s hurts my soul when I see individuals pay for items or services with a debit card. Those who are using debit cards or paying cash are basically throwing money out the window.

I think this blog provided enough detail to debunk the belief that applying for credit cards will hurt your credit score.

In the short term, yes, you’ll be “dinged” a few points but in the long term the benefits (e.g. decreased credit utilization, positive payment history, more points to redeem for flights, etc.) far outweigh the few points lost.

I would encourage you to share this article with others because it is a critical building block for their future.

So who is inspired to put their debit card down and begin maximizing credit card points, while simultaneously improving your credit score?


3 comments

  1. Not sure which “rewards” you’re referring to but if you’re talking about rewards to your credit score, there’s no hard and fast rule to when it will improve because there are a lot of other factors that make up your credit score. But having a credit card will def help (if you pay it off every month). If you’re referring to your travel as the reward, it depends on what CC you choose. But you are able to redeem the points as soon as they are deposited in your account which ultimately depends on how fast you meet the spending requirement. Some CCs only require $1000 for the reward points, while others require $25,000.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s